Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-43941049-20190929224348

So this is a whole lot so get ready...

I think that maybe Sophie and Keefe met once before that day in the hallway in book 1. Like when they were kids. Maybe when Sophie had that allergy reaction and when Keefe got assigned to give a letter in the forbidden cities. If you think about it Sophie was 9 when the accident happened. This is her counting by human terms so in Elvin terms she would be 10. Keefe in the memory that he got back was 10 or 11 so it could have happened in the same year because Keefe is about a few months older than Sophie. Another thing is that Sophie and Keefe became friends pretty fast in book 1 like immediately after they met. Another thing that supports this theory is that when Keefe joined the Neverseen Mr.Forkle and I think it was Tigeran ( Did I spell it right?) Sorta supported Keefe I think this was mentioned in Lodestar. Mr. Forkle even goes to say that Sophie understands Keefe in ways no one ever will and that Sophie should listen to her heart when trusting Keefe. It kinda sounds like the Blackswan trusts Keefe in a way. I mean most of the characters either got scared of Keefe, hated him or at least mistrusted him after that incident, but the Blackswan and Sophie did give Keefe a chance. Could it be because they have met before? Maybe Keefe even helped a little when Sophie got the allergy reaction. Going back to their understanding of each other,  Keefe was able to calm Sophie down whenever she enhances him. He could do this automatically and very easily that time with Dimitar and he also did not react that much like the others when Sophie enhanced him the first time. Could this be because Sophie has already done it before when she had the reaction? We also found out at that time Sophie was given Limbium in the first place because they were trying to fix her abilities ( I forgot when they mentioned this). If you remember Limbium is to shapen the brain and abilities( I think). So if her abilities got messed up then that means she could have had the enhancer ability and enhanced Keefe. Keefe could have helped with her by keeping her calm too and maybe try doing other stuff with her emotions to try to fix the problem. He may be able to do other things because when he tries to describe what he did when he was calming Sophie down he said he just ( not exactly what he said but..) went to her emotional center and kinda shifted her emotions. So maybe he could do more. What he can already do has let her keep her focus in tough situations so I believe it could have helped her in the pre allergy reaction with her abilities messing up. Anyway, back to the point when Keefe was helping her with her emotions maybe he did something wrong because it was his first time and must have been overwhelming, and that let him and his father have access to her emotions without contact. So two plot wholes in the theory would be that Keefe was sent to London while Sophie lives in San Diego and Keefe didn't manifest at 10 ( did he?). So maybe his mom lied about the location for security purposes ( except the Legacy cover is in London so  I don't think she lied...) or another scenario is maybe Sophie was in London. Sophie doesn't remember the memory, so maybe she and her family went to London for like a vacation or something. Anyway, if she did go to London she may have crossed paths with the Neverseen or Keefe first and that's what caused the ability disruption. It would make more sense for something or someone Elvin to cause the distribution than a human. It probably was something big according to how much the Black swan goes to hide the memory from her. That and the fact that Physic dropped from the Council after that incident. Going back to the plot hole about Keefe not manifesting thing... maybe it was Sophies supreme enhancing? I mean I feel like her abilities got messed up a lot because of the memory Sophie got back in Flashback about ( not exactly this is from my memory) Amy yelling at Sophie to stop with fear in her eyes and Amy looked almost scared of Sophie. So if her abilities got messed up a lot then maybe she was able to enhance a lot more than usual. She is the Moonlark afterall so she may have triggered Keefe's ability temporarily before he manifested. Now you can finally give yourselves a pat on the back because you have completed reading my theory congrats! Yeah, it was a lot, so, sorry. 