Talk:Black Swan/@comment-27162116-20151121180237/@comment-31903430-20170503025209

Physic cannot be Jolie because in Exile, Mr.Forkle looked really surprised that Grady thought they murdered Jolie. Sophie said it as if the Black Swan never considered it murder. If Jolie was Physic, Jolie wouldn't let Grady, Edaline, and Brant grieve like that.