Talk:Sophie's Biological Parents/@comment-44544645-20191223184323/@comment-72.80.59.247-20191227004400

I have the exact same equation down, same results, same theories. I kept thinking that she's always one person off, it's always the person standing next to the person she guessed.

1)Kenric- Oralie is: a) on the coucil. b) (was) in love with him. (we love you ,Kenric:,(

2)Mr. Forkle- Tiergan is: a) fellow collective member.

3)Bronte- Oralie is: a) council.

Another point: When Sophie confronted Mr. Forkle in Neverseen, Granite was right there. When Sophie asked why she couldn't know who her parents are, Granite and Forkle kept looking at each other. In Nightfall, when Sophie asked Tiergan if he knew who her parents are, he didn't exactly respond but he did seem to know a lot about Project Moonlark, hinting that he was involved. I'm wondering if Tiergan Knows who her parents are, or if he is her father himself.

Also, Oralie and Tiergan don't seem to have much of a connection to eachother.

My Prentice Theory: If Tiergan is Sophies father, then that could explain why Tiergan was so upset about Prentice. Prentice would have sacrificed himself for Tiergan's child and Tiergan might feel guilty about that, so it was only natural that he would want to make sure that Prentice's son was safe and cared for.

Another thing I was thinking of is Keefe. How could he have missed that ? He's looking for bio-daddy and bio-mommy and he isn't looking at the blonde telepath, who is in the Black Swan, who cares about Sophie! So maybe Shannon doesn't wan't Sophie to look into that one just yet. And I'm not sure how many people noticed this, but Oralie is hardly mentioned in Flashback, and then next book, boom, bombshell, she's Sophie's mom. In Legacy, Tiergan doesn't get much page time either.

Last point: Most of the bio-daddy theories have a bunch of huge holes and disclaimers, but I've been tracking Tiergan through the series and this theory is pretty much seemless. So unless Sophie's father is an unknown elf we haven't met (and if we haven't yet, it's not likely we will),all the roads point to Tiergan.