Talk:Sophie and Fitz/@comment-37530514-20181117164415

Hey guys, Keefoster shipper with a question here

Whenever someone says they have proof for Fitzphie, they always say that it's because either 1. He found her and took her to the lost cities or 2.'''He's been there all along/She's liked him all along. '''For a while I was like, okay fair point, but now that I think about it I don't see how those two things are proof. Hear me out because I want to know- '''How are those love and not circumstance? For  "he '''found her and took her to the lost cities", why does that matter? ALVAR looked for her first. The reason he even knew and could look for her is because he was Alden's son. I'm sure if Keefe and Dex had been Alden's sons, they would've looked for her too, and then this argument wouldn't make ANY sense. But what I'm saying is, Fitz didn't go looking for her because he cared about her- He didn't know her. He might've cared about the girl's safety, but he can't have cared about Sophie specifically because he didn't know her. I just don't see how this is a proof, and I really want to know!!!

Second, for "he's been there all along/She's liked him all along" I don't see how this works either. It's circumstance that he's been there all along, because he's Alden's son- that has nothing to do with caring for her. The other two boys, Dex and Keefe, and even Tam, can't have been there all along because they hadn't met her. And if you mean he's been there all along as in he's cared for her, well...she and Fitz have probably had the rockiest relationship of all of the boys when it comes to not being there for each other. Also, "she's liked him all along" doesn't make much sense either- It's basically saying because you have a crush on someone, they are perfect for you. Well, I've had a crush on someone for three years, and recently decided I didn't anymore, because they aren't "perfect" for me. If I had used this argument and said "Oh he's perfect for me because I've liked him for so long" that would be pretty silly, wouldn't it? In fact, that argument could be turned around for Keefe and Dex- KEEFE has liked SOPHIE all along. And it's very similar for Dex.

It would be like me saying Alvar should be with Sophie because he looked for her first. Or Alina should be with Alden because she liked him first. Or (hehe) Keefe should be with Sophie because he liked her all along.

I REALLY hope this doesn't sound mean!! I really want to know, because I keep hearing these arguments everywhere and they just don't hold up for me. Love ya Fitzphies lol


 * throws candy and flowers and hugs and a little keefoster propaganda*

jk


 * throws candy and more hugs*