Talk:Book 8: Legacy/@comment-47.184.159.121-20191227221345

okay, time to write a huge thing about who Sophie's dad could be. fight through it with

Gethen: Okay, a lot of you believe Gethen is Sophie's dad. It is actually really believable. Mr. Forkle warned that it would tear the world apart for Sophie, blah blah, but if Sophie knew that Gethen was her dad, it could tear her world apart. Of course, that could just be referring to Oralie. Also, Gethen is a Telepath and Sophie's enhancing is really strong on Empaths and Telepaths. On the other hand, Lady Cadence said the Black Swan wouldn't have given Sophie the abilities of her parents. Along with that, Mr. Forkle said that Sophie's parents knew that they were her parents. If Gethen was Sophie's dad, why wouldn't he just come out and say so? This raises so many other questions like if Gethen's Sophie's dad was his memory erased of that fact that he is? or If he is, is he to scared to tell the Neverseen? Gethen is a good assumption, but there is still much question about him being Sophie's dad.

Elwin Elwin is like the second most possibility y'all talk about. Elwin has always been there for Sophie (personally, I hope that Elwin is not Sophie's dad, but I'm trying to keep this to facts, not opinions). When Sophie first meets Elwin this conversation happens: