Talk:Book 7: Flashback/@comment-2601:644:680:FB1:E002:4CF0:8E96:C2B1-20190116030735/@comment-2606:A000:1128:4169:FD76:A10A:F2CB:7C33-20190122201152

I personally don't believe this, and here are my reasons (yes, i did copy and paste this from another discussion I had, but it's my writing)

ok, so Lady Gisela. Ummm.....I honestly don’t know what to think of this theory. I mean, I wouldn’t be surprised if Sophie was somehow related to Keefe in some way (cousin, distant relative, etc) because honestly, it would be heartbreaking for all the Sokeefe shippers, and we ALL KNOW HOW MUCH SHANNON LOVES TO MURDER HER READERS!! But I can’t see Lady Gisela as Sophie’s mom. Shannon kinda already played the Mom In The Neverseen card with Keefe, and to find out that Lady Gisela is Sophie’s mother....sure, it would be a “surprise”, but her reaction would be kind of....repeated? Does that make any sense? Like she’s already questioning whether she was made to be a “natural killer”. And if Lady Gisela was Sophie’s mom, then she’d have to deal with not being able to love Keefe (which would probably make her realize she has feelings for him, to be honest), and the fact that her mother is LADY GISELA, and somehow still find time to focus on the Neverseen and everything else. Knowing Sophie, I don’t think it would be a smart move to do that, because of her anxiety and how she reacts to things like this. It wouldn’t be good for the plot, because right now, they’re so far behind it’s not even funny, and having Sophie go through this would put them back so much that I’m not actually sure if they could make it up. I’d like Sophie’s parents to be a surprise, but help move the plot forward, not sett it back.