Talk:Caches/@comment-38091275-20190219195734

Odd theory, but hear me out.

Sophie never had Kenric's real cache.

Oralie gave her the cache, but she knew Sophie couldn't get into it. It was merely a bargaining chip. So Kenric gave her a false copy to give to Sophie and destroyed the real one (or gave it to the Black Swan).

That's how the Neverseen was willing to give back a fake one. They never had the real version in the first place.