Talk:Keefe and Sophie/@comment-78.100.171.241-20190217095756

Ok so I'm posting my theory here, even though the "Parentage Theories" thread is below, so we don't have to scroll down a lot to read.

Here we go:



​​​​I read a comment yesterday suggesting that Caprise Redek is Sophie's mother, and at first, I was like "whaaaaaaa?" But it kinda makes sense...Caprise is still sort of mysterious, and I'm not buying the whole "she should have been more careful" reaction to Cyrah's death, because it seems too ominous and coincidental that Caprise was present right before Wylie's mom's death.

Not to mention the fact that, like Sophie, Caprise has blond hair (I'm assuming this because Marella does) and we don't know much about her, which means she's shrouded in secrets and--

WAIT. A. MINUTE. Do we even know Caprise's ability? She might be an Enhancer for all we know...

OH. MY. GOSH. What if her unfortunate accident wasn't really an "accident?" What if instead of falling off the balcony and landing on her head (sorry for the wording 😂), someone pushed her off and made it seems like an act of "clumsiness"? We all know that accidents don't happen in the Lost Cities, especially when Sophie and Co. investigate in past incidents (i.e Jolie's death, Cyrah's death, the Everblaze fires in the Forbidden Cities, the capture of Brant, Ruy, and Gethan that turned out to be a conspiratorial plot, and so on and so forth).

WHAT IF SOMEONE TAMPERED WITH CAPRISE'S BRAIN (a Telepath like Gethan, perhaps), and that's why she doesn't seem to have a strong recollection of the day Cyrah died and still has physiological issues from her "incident" which happened years before. The same person (or group of people *ahem* *cough The Neverseen *cough*) might have washed her memory, and she always seems to be struggling to have "good days" and make sense of her surroundings. Marella was also saying how her mother acted weird after she mentioned the starstone to her... but the real question is, "why does she still have the starstone with her all these years?" The fact that she still kept it with her (and hid it from everyone) shows that she might remember something from the day of Cyrah's death (and possibly be more involved in the case).

This was probably all a ploy to make sure she doesn't remember or speak about Cyrah's death, and to dispatch Sophie's biological mother so the Moonlark is more vulnerable.

Also, did Sophie ever meet Caprise? I don't think so, because although we didn't pay much attention to her, she might have played a larger role in the whole series than we think, and might be hiding under the guise of a minor character, only to SPRING OUT AND SUPRISE US ALL LATER...

You see, it was all planned out very well, and we were all unsuspecting mice as always...

Caprise might be Sophie's biological mother, and although that might seem ulikely and farfetched now, we all saw (or read ;) ) how Mr. Forkle turned out to be Master Leto and Sir Astin, Tiergan as Granite, Juline as Squall, Livvy as Physic (though we didn't know that Livvy existed until Nightfall), Brant as the Neverseen's Pyrokinetic-in-training, Fintain as the super evil Pyrokinetic villian, Lady Gisela as the malicious previous leader of the Neverseen, and Alvar as The Boy Who Disappeared, proving that some of the key characters, both good and evil, were right under our noses all along!



WOAH. I might have gotten a little carried away...*looks at entire theory sheepishly*

BUT, please please please PLEASE let me know what you all think, because my brain has latched onto this idea and I need you guys to give me feeback (both supportive and unsupportive, I don't mind!)

~ (▰^◡^▰) Mystical Woodlands