Board Thread:Clubs/@comment-37609893-20190615202011/@comment-44544645-20191207052422

Although I think Oralie shouldn't have donated DNA, Sophie's reaction was too extreme. It kind of reminded me of Harry in Dumbledore's office in Order of the Pheonix:

Fifteen-year-old: YOU KNEW THIS HUGE SECRET ABOUT ME AND YOU COULD'VE TOLD ME AND YOU SHOULD'VE TOLD ME AND YOU DIDN'T AND

Mentor: I had a good reason, sort of.....

Fifteen-year-old: I WANT TO BREAK YOUR STUFF AND RAGE AND SCREAM AND

Mentor: Yeah, go ahead.

I really hope Sophie and Oralie make up in Book 9. Yes, Oralie shouldn't have donated DNA, and I think she could have handled the confrontation better, but other than that, she's been supportive of Sophiei and has taken huge risks for her and almost got kicked off the Council. She isn't Sophie's parent figure, or anything close to it, but she's never tried to be, and Sophie doesn't need another parent. She just tries to help Sophie in any way she can. And I think what Sophie thought about Oralie lying to her was way too extreme. Oralie didn't lie for Sophie's entire life, she just witheld a few crucial secrets, exactly like pretty much every member of the Black Swan, as well as several of Sophie's friends. Sophie withholds stuff all the time.

I hate the Everblaze cover as well. And how come Elwin wasn't there when they were making the frissyn? Not only did everyone most likely have some degree of smoke inhalation problems, Oralie got hit with melting amethyst, which is over 1700 degrees Celsius. Even with fireproof clothing, she probably needed medical attention.

Can I join this?